Defending the School Choice Rights of Arizona’s Parents and Kids: Hallford v. Department of Education


Imagine being a parent and finally finding the perfect educational opportunity for your child, only to have it taken away by the government. This heart-wrenching scenario became a reality for a group of parents in Arizona. However, they didn’t stand idly by; they reached out to the Goldwater Institute, a champion for parental rights, to fight for them in court.

hello world!


The Back Story

The introduction of Arizona's Empowerment Scholarship Account (ESA) program aims to empower parents by providing them with a say in their children's education. This school choice program allows all families to freely choose the public school, private schools, or even religious schools that best suit their children's requirements. Rather than solely funding government-operated schools, this program redirects allocated resources to support the selected educational path, enabling parents to access specialized services for their children while promoting public education.

Regrettably, the administration of the ESA program by the Arizona Department of Education has presented significant challenges for families eager to exercise their educational choice. They enforced a comprehensive set of regulations known as the Handbook, which imposed strict limitations on voucher recipients. According to state regulations, when an agency implements rules like these, it must adhere to procedures that guarantee public involvement in the consideration of proposed rules. However, the Department disregarded these regulations and arbitrarily implemented the Handbook without involving the public.

The Department required parents to regularly submit expense reports in order to receive reimbursement for expenses. The Department delayed in reviewing these reports, resulting in parents experiencing prolonged waits to receive their funds. Consequently, parents were forced to bear the financial burden of essential tutoring and educational materials, impacting their out-of-pocket expenses. In some unfortunate instances, parents had no alternative but to withdraw their children from tutoring programs, causing a significant disruption to their K-12 education.

The Goldwater Institute stepped in and took action in response to these injustices. They filed a lawsuit on behalf of four Arizona families affected by the Department's illegal and obstructive handling of the ESA program. The lawsuit aimed to challenge the Handbook's legality, end the Department's practice of withholding funding during reviews, and prevent any other unlawful restrictions on parental rights.


The Struggle of Arizona's Parents and Children

The challenges these Arizona parents face serve as a powerful reminder of the significance of allowing parents to freely choose the education that best meets their children's needs. It is undeniable that parents possess an intimate understanding of their children's unique requirements. Each child has their distinct strengths, weaknesses, and learning preferences. By granting parents the ability to send their child to a school that aligns with these individual factors, they can secure the tailored education and support necessary for their children's development.

This freedom of choice in education empowers parents to navigate beyond the confines of the traditional school system. It acknowledges that one-size-fits-all approaches may violate the educational needs of children who thrive in different environments. By embracing a more flexible approach, parents can play an active role in shaping their children's educational journey, ensuring they receive the personalized attention and nurturing they deserve.


Goldwater Institute: The Champions of Parental Rights

The Goldwater Institute is the national leader in the school choice movement in the United States. This influential organization is dedicated to safeguarding and championing the rights of parents when it comes to their children's education. Their primary objective is to protect individuals and families from excessive government control. They firmly assert that parents should possess the ultimate authority in choosing their child's school, and they tirelessly advocate to preserve and uphold this essential parental right.


Taking a Stand: Hallford v. Department of Education

The Hallford v. Department of Education case was brought before an Arizona court, with the Goldwater Institute serving as the legal representative for the parents advocating for their rights regarding their children's education. These courageous Arizona families, the plaintiffs in this case, recognized the significance of their parental rights and were determined to challenge the system. They understood that their children's future was at stake and were resolute in their refusal to allow bureaucratic hurdles and unnecessary regulations to hinder their children's educational journey.

The defendants, the Arizona Department of Education, were opposing them in the courtroom. As the entity responsible for implementing and overseeing the ESA program, their actions have unfortunately infringed upon the fundamental parental rights at the core of this case. These parents firmly believe they have the right to actively shape their children's educational experience, including the choice of schools and the curriculum, as protected by the state constitution.


The Charges

The Goldwater Institute, representing the parents, filed a lawsuit against the Department of Education on the grounds of several unlawful practices. First and foremost, they challenged the Department's arbitrary adoption of the Handbook without seeking public input, a clear violation of state law. By ignoring the required procedures, the Department denied parents their right to have a say in the rules that directly affected their children's education.

Furthermore, the lawsuit challenged the Department's practice of withholding funding during the review process. The delays in processing expense reports and subsequent payments placed an unfair burden on parents, forcing them to pay for necessary educational resources out of their pockets. It undermined the financial stability of these families and jeopardized their children's access to vital educational support.

The Goldwater Institute continues to fight vigorously on behalf of the four families, seeking justice and defending the rights of parents to choose the best educational path for their children.

sad girl holding parent

The fight to uphold parental rights in Arizona continues unabated. Driven by an unwavering dedication to individual freedoms, the Goldwater Institute remains resolute in its mission to empower parents to direct their children's education. The landmark case of Hallford v. Department of Education serves as a poignant reminder of the challenges faced by parents and children in Arizona while emphasizing the significance of safeguarding the rights of all parents across the nation.

As parents, it is our solemn duty to advocate for the well-being and future of our children. The ability to select the school of their choice that caters to their unique needs is an integral part of fulfilling this responsibility. We must join forces to champion parental rights and tirelessly fight for the educational opportunities our children rightfully deserve. Together, let us stand firm in defending these rights and ensuring a bright future for our children.

G - Goldwater Institute
Subscribe to our

Monthly Newsletter

for Legal Insight on Parents Rights the latest in public school news, and free resources to arm you as an advocate of your child's education.

"*" indicates required fields


Contact the Goldwater Institute.