Securing Parents' Voices: The Crucial Fairfax County School Board Case

Debra Tisler

As parents, it is natural for us to seek information about our children’s schools. We value transparency, accountability, and the responsible utilization of our tax dollars. However, there has been a troubling rise in instances where school district authorities resist parental inquiries or calls for reforms.

In a remarkable occurrence that has attracted national attention, the Fairfax County, Virginia, school board took legal action against two mothers who sought information about how their tax dollars were being utilized to cover the legal fees of school personnel. This article explores the specifics of the case and highlights the significance of safeguarding parents’ right to be informed about legislation, policies, curriculum, teachers, and the introduction of necessary changes.

hello world!


The Backstory: Parents' Quest for Transparency and Accountability

Debra Tisler, one of the mothers in this case, expressed concerns regarding the excessive expenditure of her school district on legal fees. In her quest for transparency, she utilized the Freedom of Information Act of the state and submitted a request for pertinent documents. The school board duly complied, providing over 1,000 pages of records. Little did Debra realize the firestorm that was about to ensue.

Another parent, Callie Oettinger, took the initiative to share some of these documents on her website, With careful redaction of sensitive details, she disseminated select records relating to the superintendent, the school board, and investigations concerning cyber hacking incidents and challenges faced during the implementation of virtual learning in Fairfax County Public Schools. 

Callie firmly believed that her actions fell within the ambit of the First Amendment's protection of free speech, recognizing the fundamental rights of parents in shaping the upbringing of their children.


Goldwater Institute: Protecting Parental Rights Pro Bono

Recognizing the gravity of the situation, Debra Tisler and Callie Oettinger sought legal assistance to defend their rights. They reached out to the Goldwater Institute, an organization known for its commitment to protecting individual liberties. Goldwater Institute stepped in to provide pro bono representation, understanding the significance of this case in safeguarding parents' right to know.


The Lawsuit Unveiled: Who is Suing Whom?

In light of Debra and Callie's involvement, the Fairfax County School Board, as an official body, initiated legal proceedings against them. The board sought to compel Debra to return the documents she had lawfully obtained through the Freedom of Information Act. 

Additionally, they sought a court order requiring Callie to remove the published information from her website, relating to matters concerning the classroom and the education of children. This lawsuit highlighted the ongoing struggle to uphold parental rights and the protections afforded by the First Amendment.


Challenging the Status Quo: What Are They Suing For?

The crux of the lawsuit revolves around the fundamental question: Do parents have the right to publish information they obtained legally from the government? The Fairfax County School Board argues against this right, asserting that certain documents should be kept confidential, even if provided in response to a Freedom of Information Act request.

However, the Supreme Court has made it clear that individuals have a constitutional right to publish legally obtained information, even if the government would prefer it to remain secret. A notable precedent is the 2001 case of Bartnicki v. Vopper, where the Court ruled in favor of a radio talk show host who broadcasted an illegally recorded conversation. The Court reasoned that as long as the recipient of the recording obtained it legally, they had the right to disseminate the information. 

Similarly, the 1973 case of New York Times v. United States upheld the right of newspapers to publish the "Pentagon Papers" despite their stolen nature. These cases establish that parents should unquestionably have the right to publish documents received through a Freedom of Information Act request.

The lawsuit between the Fairfax County School Board, Debra Tisler, and Callie Oettinger is currently pending in the Fairfax County Circuit Court in Virginia. The School Board filed its complaint on September 27, 2021, setting the stage for a significant legal battle. The case remains ongoing, with both sides presenting their arguments and defending their positions.


The Implications and Importance: Fighting for Parents' Rights

The outcome of this case holds immense implications for parents across the country. It goes beyond the specific circumstances in Fairfax County. It sets a precedent for parental rights to know and publish information about their children's schools. The pivotal role of parents in molding their children's education cannot be overstated, as their capacity to obtain and share information directly influences their decision-making.

Protecting parents' right to know ensures they can hold their school districts accountable for using tax dollars and the quality of education. It empowers parents to voice concerns, ask questions, and demand transparency. Moreover, it upholds the principles of free speech and the First Amendment, highlighting the importance of open dialogue and the ability to share information that impacts the public interest.

The Fairfax County School Board v. Tisler and Oettinger case highlights the fight for parents' right to know in the United States. Debra Tisler and Callie Oettinger, backed by the Goldwater Institute, bravely challenged the status quo and asserted their constitutional right to publish information obtained legally. This case is not just about two mothers—it's about all parents who want to actively participate in their children's education.

As parents, we are vested in our children's schools and well-being. We deserve transparency, accountability, and the freedom to access and share information that affects our children's lives. The outcome of this case will shape the landscape of parental rights and determine whether we can continue to be engaged advocates for our children's education. Let us stand together and support the defense of parental rights because knowledge is power, and parents have the right to know.

G - Goldwater Institute
Subscribe to our

Monthly Newsletter

for Legal Insight on Parents Rights the latest in public school news, and free resources to arm you as an advocate of your child's education.

"*" indicates required fields


Contact the Goldwater Institute.